Posts Tagged ‘Once Upon a Time Challenge’

Castle in the Air

by Diana Wynne Jones

HarperCollins, 1990

Source: public library

Read it because . . . I love Howl’s Moving Castle

 

Many moons ago,* I read this review over at things mean a lot and learned that Diana Wynne Jones wrote two companion books to Howl’s Moving Castle. Since I completely love and adore Howl’s Moving Castle, I decided I absolutely had to read Castle in the Air and I was going to do it for the Once Upon a Time Challenge and it was going to be Awesome.

Well, I read it. But folks – and this pains me to say this – it was not awesome.

I know. It doesn’t seem possible. Diana Wynne Jones not be awesome? After I finished reading Castle in the Air, I had the hardest time admitting out loud that I didn’t like it. It’s been a few months since I read it so most of the specifics have already left my brain, (and I don’t even want to skim the book to refresh my memory), but from what I remember the book felt not like the carefully work I’ve come to expect from Jones but like it was haphazardly thrown together. I never connected with any of the main characters. When Sophie, Howl and Calcifer arrived on the scene, it felt like a last-minute decision, like Jones suddenly remembered that this was a companion to Howl’s Moving Castle and she better find a way to tie the books together.

Did anyone else feel this way about Castle in the Air, or am I alone in my disappointment? I haven’t given up on Jones, but I don’t think I’m going to read the third book in the series, either.

Other reviews: BookLust, Chachic’s Book Nook, Dogear Diary, things mean a lot,

Did you write a review?  Let me know and I’ll add it to the list!

*I just realized that I started this review the exact same way I started the Howl’s Moving Castle review I wrote two years ago.  Weird.

Advertisements

Read Full Post »

This final Neverwhere Read Along post is coming to you many, many weeks late, but alas, such is life. The library is always crazy busy in the summer and my personal life was a bit nutty for awhile there, too, so my blogging has suffered. I really wanted to get this post up, though, if only just to say what a fantastic experience the read along was and how much I enjoyed Neverwhere.

Since I finished the book weeks ago, any brilliant thoughts I had have long since fled my brain, which means that all I have left are rambling thoughts. So. Some ramblings:

When I found out who Croup and Vandemar were working for, I gasped out loud. Once I resumed breathing, and thus supplying much-needed oxygen to my brain, the obviousness of it hit me like an anvil. It made perfect sense. Who else could it be? This is London Below, where darkness and the creatures and people we expect to be evil are not. Why wouldn’t the opposite be true as well? Then I found myself trying to recall everything everyone else participating in this group read had said about all the characters in the book. Unless I’m remembering incorrectly, (and there’s a very good chance that I am, since I read a lot of posts in a short period of time), the people who were rereading Neverwhere had been decidedly silent about this particular character. In hindsight, I should have paid closer attention to who said what about each character because I probably could have figured this out a lot sooner if I had.

I wasn’t surprised by the ending, but that didn’t bother me very much since half the fun of reading Gaiman’s work is the journey he takes you on, not the destination. That being said, I did expect Richard to change his mind about returning to London sooner than he did. It was fitting, though, that he went through another “ordeal” before he could return. He still needed to figure out exactly who he was and what he wanted from life, and in fielding the real Gary’s doubts about his sanity he realized the truth about himself. I love that he created his own door, and that the marquis was the one to greet him (in typical marquis fashion, of course).

And that’s about all my brain has to offer at the moment! I enjoyed this book immensely and the read along was a barrel of fun. Thanks to Carl for being such a superb host, and thanks to the bloggers who stopped by and commented here. You all rock.

Read Full Post »

Here’s the second round of questions for the Neverwhere Read Along!  I’m so glad I signed up for this.  I’m enjoying myself immensely.

1.  Chapter 6 begins with Richard chanting the mantra, “I want to go home”.  How do you feel about Richard and his reactions at this point to the unexpected adventure he finds himself on?

I don’t really blame Richard for wishing he was home since he now has, as he put it, “the projected life expectancy of a suicidal fruitfly” (89). In fact, I think that’s the reaction many protagonists have when they find themselves on unexpected adventures. Didn’t Alice and Dorothy just want to go home, too? Before he can go home (if he ever does), however, I think Richard needs to learn how to be a more active, and less passive, participant in his own life.

2.  The Marquis de Carabas was even more mysterious and cagey during the first part of this week’s reading.  What were your reactions to him/thoughts about him as you followed his activities?

I decided a while ago that I would stop trying to pin the Marquis down. I’m still puzzled by his actions, am unclear as to what motivates him to behave the way he does, and don’t entirely trust him. I’m just going to ride the story out and wait to see what – if anything – Gaiman reveals about this character. It will be an entertaining ride, I’m sure, because even though I feel like I have to keep an eye on the Marquis at all times, he has some of the best lines in the book. (My current favorite: “What a refreshing mind you have, young man. There really is nothing quite like total ignorance, is there?” [94])

3.  How did you feel about the Ordeal of the Key?

At first I was a little confused about what was going on, and then it just made me terribly sad. All those people driven to end their own lives . . .

4.  This section of the book is filled with moments.  Small, sometimes quite significant, moments that pass within a few pages but stick with you.  What are one or two of these that you haven’t discussed yet that stood out to you, or that you particularly enjoyed.

Those moments are one of the reasons I love reading Gaiman’s work. Some of them are so fleeting, like this one:

“There are no shepherds in Shepherd’s Bush. I’ve been there. It’s just houses and stores and roads and the BBC. That’s all,” pointed out Richard, flatly.

“There are shepherds,” said Hunter, from the darkness just next to Richard’s ear. “Pray you never meet them.” (90)

And just like that, Gaiman has me wondering, slightly nervously, about the shepherds in Shepherd’s Bush. In just a few short lines, with seemingly little effort, he’s added yet another dimension to this world he’s created. He gives us just enough information to get our imaginations racing, which I think is far more effective writing technique than if he had described in detail just why we wouldn’t want to meet these shepherds.

5.  Any other things/ideas that you want to talk about from this section of the book?

I loved this:

Old Bailey was not, intrinsically, one of those people put in the world to tell jokes. Despite this handicap, he persisted in trying. He loved to tell shaggy-dog stories of inordinate length, which would end in a sad pun although, often as not, Old Bailey would be unable to remember it by the time he got there. The only public for Old Bailey’s jokes consisted of a small captive audience of birds, who, particularly the rooks, viewed his jokes as deep and philosophical parables containing profound and penetrating insights into what it meant to be human, and who would actually ask him, from time to time, to tell them another of his amusing stories. (147-148)

Read Full Post »

It’s time for the Neverwhere Read Along, (part of the Once Upon a Time Challenge), which is hosted by Carl at Stainless Steel Droppings.  For Part I we read the Prologue and the first five chapters.  (I had a very, very hard time putting the book down at the end of Chapter Five.  I’m not good at this whole reading patiently thing.)

Here are my answers to the first batch of questions:

1.  What do you think of our two villains thus far, Messrs. Croup and Vandemar?

Neil Gaiman has a knack for creating shadowy, intelligent villains with lightning reflexes who seem to anticipate your every move and appear and disappear without warning . . . like Croup and Vandemar. I admit it’s an impressive knack, but they completely creep me out.

2.  Thus far we’ve had a small taste of London Below and of the people who inhabit it.  What do you think of this world, this space that lies within or somewhat overlaps the space the “real world” occupies?

I feel a little in the dark about London Below. When Richard first encounters the rat-speakers, Lord Rat-speaker accuses him of being a spy from the “Upworld.” But how on earth could he be a spy if no one back in London can see him anymore? The man who brought him to the rat-speakers could see him, however, so there must be people who can reside in both worlds. At this point, I have more questions than thoughts about London Below.

3.  What ideas or themes are you seeing in these first 5 chapters of Neverwhere?  Are there any that you are particularly drawn to?

The perils of kindness is a theme that jumps out at me. Normally kindness saves your butt in fairy tales, but in saving Door’s life, Richard loses his own (mostly metaphorically, but also nearly literally). There’s still time for things to turn out the way they “should,” though. (Although perhaps they already have. The Hunter does save his life three times in Chapter Five.)

4.  We’ve met a number of secondary characters in the novel, who has grabbed your attention and why?

This will probably sound odd, but one of the many secondary characters who has grabbed my attention is the rat, Master Longtail. Even though we never hear what he says (just what other people say he’s saying), his personality shines through anyway. The fact that he steps in and orders Lord Rat-speaker to spare Richard’s life and take him to the market makes me wonder what, if any, greater role Master Longtail plays in the story.

5.  As you consider the Floating Market, what kind of things does your imagination conjure up? What would you hope to find, or what would you be looking for, at the Market?

I know the market is not literally floating, but I can’t seem to shake that image from my head. Other than that, I imagine it to be like some of the markets I went to when I was in Ecuador: a cacophony of vendors and food and people and animals. What would I be looking for at the Market? Ha, something tells me I probably would not have made it to the market. Knightsbridge . . . *shudder*

6.  If you haven’t already answered it in the questions above, what are your overall impressions of the book to this point?

So far I’m really enjoying Neverwhere. I had a very hard time putting it down at the end of Chapter Five. As I read, I marveled – once again – at what a masterful storyteller Gaiman is. Rather than describe his characters, he reveals their personalities through their own words and actions and those of the characters around them. His references range from overt to subtle (I got the Bob Marley reference in the middle of Chapter Five, but nearly missed the Alice in Wonderland reference 11 pages later). And above all, he’s entertaining. While I don’t think Neverwhere will end up on my All-Time Favorite Neil Gaiman Novel list, it’s still a great read.

Read Full Post »

Sometimes I think I live under a rock.  I’m going into my third year of blogging and this is the first I’ve heard of the Once Upon a Time Challenge.  How have I missed this?  I sure hope the rock I’m living under is comfy, ’cause apparently I spend a lot of time there!

The Once Upon a Time Challenge is hosted by one of the best challenge hosts out there, Carl at Stainless Steel Droppings.  Like the R.I.P. Challenge, there are several participation options so even the busiest of readers can partake in the event.  The challenge lasts until June 19 (good news for me since I’m joining a month into the challenge).  I’m going to participate at the “Journey” level, which basically means I’m participating without committing myself to a specific number of books.  Perfect!

So what, exactly, am I signing up for?  In Carl’s own words:

“This is a reading and viewing event that encompasses four broad categories: Fairy Tale, Folklore, Fantasy and Mythology, including the seemingly countless sub-genres and blending of genres that fall within this spectrum. The challenge continues through Tuesday, June 19th and allows for very minor (1 book only) participation as well as more immersion depending on your reading/viewing whims.”

Yep, folks, that’s three months dedicated to fairy tales and more.  Life is grand.

Anyone else joining in the fun?  What are you reading?  What do you think I should read?

Read Full Post »